Shyp Nadia
Evolution of the idea of federalism to the state independence of Ukraine (late 19th - second decade of the 20th century)Section: Historical, biographical, and book history aspects of cultural heritage research Abstract: Purpose of the study: to prove that the scientific achievements of the intellectual elite in the development of theoretical foundations of Ukrainian statehood are an important component of national history; to confirm the importance of resolving the “Ukrainian question” in the process of statehood; to recreate the gradual evolution of the idea of federalism to independence and attempts to implement them during the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917-1920. Scientific novelty. The article presents the historiosophical aspect of the struggle of the patriotic elite for the creation of an independent Ukrainian state. The announcement of the politicization of the state movement defined the boundary of the 19th - 20th centuries. Two vectors of political orientation in Ukraine were recorded: external - federalist and independent, and internal - national and social, which together constituted the theoretical basis of the state-forming idea in its multivariate nature. It is confirmed that there was not always a consensus within the political establishment in giving priority to national or social freedom, or their combination. The ambivalence of Ukrainian identity and the pressure of Bolshevik Russia, which culminated in the establishment of Soviet power in Ukraine in 1919, also made themselves felt. Therefore, by that time the goal of achieving national and political emancipation had not been realized. Keywords: “Ukrainian question”, federalization, independence, Ukrainian Central Rada, universals
Author(s) citation:
Cite: Shyp Nadia (2026). Evolution of the idea of federalism to the state independence of Ukraine (late 19th - second decade of the 20th century). Academic Papers of V. I. Vernadskyi National Library of Ukraine, (77) 511-533. (In Ukrainan). doi: https://doi.org/10.15407/np.77.511
References: - Bachynskyi, Yu. (1924). Ukraina irredenta. 3-tie vyd. Berlin: Vyd-vo Ukrainskoi molodi.
- Verstiuk, V. F. (2004). Revoliutsiia 1917-1920 rr. i ukrainskorosiiski vidnosyny [Revolution 1917-1920 and Ukrainian-Russian relations]. Ukraina i Rosiia v istorychnii retrospektyvi: Narysy: V 3 t. T.1. Ukrainski proekty v Rosiiskii imperii – Ukraine and Russia in Historical Retrospective. Essays in 3 v. V.1 Ukrainian Projects in Russian Empire, 412-498 Kyiv: Naukova dumka [in Ukrainian].
- Verstiuk, V. (2002). Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada ta yii universaly: Tretii ta Chetvertyi [Ukrainian Central Rada and its Universals: Third and Fourth]. Problemy vyvchennia istorii ukrainskoi revoliutsii 1917-1921 rr. – Problems of Study the History of Ukrainian Revolution 1917-1921, 3-14 [in Ukrainian].
- Verstiuk, V. F. Ukrainske pytannia v Rosiiskii imperii (druha polovyna XIX – pochatok XX st.). Ukrainofilstvo ta derzhavookhoronna polityka tsaryzmu. [Ukrainian question in Russian Empire (second half of 19th – early of 20th century). Ukrainianism and the state security policy of tsarism]. Ukraina i Rosiia v istorychnii retrospektyvi: Narysy: V 3 t. T.1. Ukrainski proekty v Rosiiskii imperii – Ukraine and Russia in Historical Retrospective. Essays in 3 v. V.1 Ukrainian Projects in Russian Empire, 351-411 [in Ukrainian].
- Vynnychenko, V. (1920). Vidrodzhennia natsii. Ch. II. [Rebirth of the Nation. P.II]. Kyiv-Viden [in Ukrainian].
- Hrytsak, Ya. Y. (2000). Narys istorii Ukrainy: formuvannia modernoi ukrainskoi natsii XX-XXI st. [Essay on the history of Ukraine: formation of modern Ukrainian nation 20-21 century]. [in Ukrainian].
- Hrushevsky, M. (1907). Osvobozhdenye Rossyy y Ukraynskyi vopros [Russia’s liberation and Ukrainian question]. Saint Petersburg [in Russian].
- Hrushevsky, M. (1917). Khto taki Ukraintsi i choho vony khochut [Who are Ukrainians, and what do they want]. 2nd edition, Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
- Yekelchyk, S.O. (1995). Federalizm M. Drahomanova [M. Drahomanov’s federalism]. Sotsialno-filosofski idei Mykhaila Drahomanova – Social and Philosophical Ideas of Mykhailo Drahomanov. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats, 63-73 [in Ukrainian].
- Kasianov, H. (2015). Ukraina mizh revoliutsiieiu, samostiinistiu ta okupatsiieiu [Ukraine between revolution, independence, and occupation]. In Ukraina mizh samovyznachenniam ta okupatsiieiu: 1917-1922 roky – Ukraine Between Self-Determination and Occupation: 1917-1922. Per. z nim. V. Kamianets,129-172 [in Ukrainian]
- Kovalenko, L. (2004). Zakonodavche vyrishennia ukrainskykh pytan u derzhavnykh dumakh Rosiiskoi imperii na storinkakh rosiiskomovnoi ukrainskoi presy kintsia XIX – pochatku XX stolittia [The legislative resolution of Ukrainian questions in the State Dumas of the Russian Empire as reflected in the Russian-language Ukrainian press of the late 19th and early 20th centuries]. Iurydychnyi zhurnal – Law Journal, 7, 78-83 [in Ukrainian].
- Korolov, H. (2010). Ukrainskyi federalizm v istorychnomu dyskursi (XIX – pochatok XX stolittia) [Ukrainian federalism in historical discourse (19th – early 20th centuries)] [in Ukrainian].
- Lototskyi, O. (2023). Ukrainska koloniia v Peterburzi [Ukrainian colony in Petersburg]. Khronika 2000 – Chronicle 2000, 12, 55/56, 638-806 [in Ukrainian].
- Myronets, N. (2013). Petro Stebnytskyi – spivavtor pratsi “Ukraynskyi vopros” (1914 r.) [Petro Stebnytskyi – co-author of the book “Ukrainian question” (1914). Myronets N., Piskun V., Starovoitenko I. Petro Stebnytskyi v ukrainskomu natsionalnomu zhytti (do 150-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia) – Myronets, N., Piskun, V., Starovoitenko, I. Petro Stebnytskyi in Ukrainian National Life (to 150th anniversary), 97-109 [in Ukrainian].
- Nahorna, L. (2006). Federatyvna ideia v Ukraini: tradytsii, suchasne bachennia, perspektyvy [Federative idea in Ukraine: traditions, modern view, prospects]. Istorychnyi zhurnal – Historical Journal, 5, 3-11 [in Ukrainian].
- Udod, O., Blashchuk, S., Vermenych, Ya., Kovalevska, O., and Yas, O. (2018). Narysy z sotsiokulturnoi istorii ukrainskoho istoriiepysannia: subdystsyplinarni napriamy [Essays on sociocultural history of Ukrainian history writing: subdisciplinary directions]. [in Ukrainian].
- Ovsiienko, O. F. (1999). “Ukrainske pytannia” v studentskomu rusi [“Ukrainian question” in student movement]. “Ukrainske pytannia” v Rosiiskii imperii (kinets XIX – pochatok XX st.) – “Ukrainian question” in Russian Empire (end of the 19th – early 20th centuries), 193-247 [in Ukrainian].
- Piskun, V. (2013). Petro Stebnytskyi pro kliuchovi pytannia ukrainskoho natsionalno-vyzvolnoho rukhu ta yoho perspektyvy [Petro Stebnytskyi on key issues of Ukrainian national liberation movement, and its prospects]. Myronets N., Piskun V., Starovoitenko I. Petro Stebnytskyi v ukrainskomu natsionalnomu zhytti (do 150-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia) – Myronets, N., Piskun, V., Starovoitenko, I. Petro Stebnytskyi in Ukrainian National Life (to 150th anniversary), 40-64 [in Ukrainian].
- Plokhiy, S. (2011). Velykyi peredil. Nezvychaina istoriia Mykhaila Hrushevskoho [The great redivision. Unusual history of Mykhailo Hrushevsky] [in Ukrainian].
- Soldatenko, V. F. (2023). Kontseptsii ukrainskoi revoliutsii ta natsionalnoi sobornosti u svitli politychnoi praktyky 1917-1920 rokiv [Conceptions of Ukrainian revolution and national unity in the view of political practice 1917-1920] [in Ukrainian].
- Starovoitenko, I. (2013). Zhyttievymy marshrutamy Petra Stebnytskoho: Horenychi-Kyiv-Peterburh-Kyiv [Following the Petro Stebnytskyi’s life journey: Horenychi-Kyiv-Petersburg-Kyiv]. Myronets N., Piskun V., Starovoitenko I. Petro Stebnytskyi v ukrainskomu natsionalnomu zhytti (do 150-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia) – Myronets, N., Piskun, V., Starovoitenko, I. Petro Stebnytskyi in Ukrainian National Life (to 150th anniversary), 15-39 [in Ukrainian].
- Dornik, V., Kasianov, H., Lib, P., Liaidinger, H., Millier, A., Musial, B., and Rasevych, V. (2015). Ukraina mizh samovyznachenniam ta okupatsiieiu: 1917-1922 roky [Ukraine between self-determination and occupation: 1917-1922].V. Kamianets (Trans.). [in Ukrainian].
- Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada: Dokumenty i materialy. U 2 t. T. 2 [Ukrainian Central Rada. Documents and materials. In 2 v. V.2]. (1997). [in Ukrainian].
- Ukrainskyi vybir: politychni systemy XX stolittia i poshuk vlasnoi modeli suspilnoho rozvytku [Ukrainian choice: political systems in the 20th century and search for the own model of public development]. (2007). [in Ukrainian]
- Ukraynskyi vopros. Sostavleno sotrudnykamy zhurnala “Ukraynskaia zhyzn” [Ukrainian question. Compiled by staff of the journal “Ukrainian life”]. (1917). Moscow [in Russian].
|